Monday, May 28, 2018

New England Donald Ross Trip Review

One of my many goals in golf is to play every golf course designed by Donald Ross.  Mr. Ross designed approximately 375 golf courses.  I'm currently at 148 courses played so I have a ways to go.  In order to accomplish this goal I will be taking several short trip to New England, Ohio, and Michigan.  I just returned from one of these trips where I played nine Ross courses in four days.  It was a wonderful trip and I was privileged to see a nice variety of courses from the greatest golf architect of all time.

The trip began at Longmeadow Country Club in Longmeadow, Massachusetts.  Longmeadow is a 1922 Donald Ross design.  Longmeadow is one of the hardest Ross courses with a large number of 420+ yard par 4's.  Recent tree removal has really improved the site lines and vistas on the course.
3rd & 7th Holes
10th Hole
16th Hole
 After Longmeadow, I made the 45 minute drive down to Hartford, Connecticut to play Wampanoag.  Wampanoag is a 1924 Donald Ross design that doesn't get the attention that nearby Hartford Golf Club does.  The course has very good bones and could be really great with a proper restoration.
6th Hole
16th Hole

18th Hole
Day two of the trip began at Shennecossett Golf Course in Groton, Connecticut.  Shennecossett is a 1916 Donald Ross municipal course that sold the property containing the original 5th to 7th holes in 1997.  They hired Mark Mungeam to design three new holes near the water.  You will not be seeing pictures of those holes as I prefer to focus on the Ross holes
12th Hole

13th Hole
18th Hole
Day two continued at another public Ross course, Winnapaug Country Club in Westerly, Rhode Island.  Winnapaug was designed in 1922 and is one of those courses that falls into the "good bones" category of Ross courses.  It has not been well preserved but you can still see the potential.
3rd Hole

15th Hole
The final course on Day two was the course that this entire trip was planned around, The Misquamicut Club in Watch Hill, Rhode Island.  Misquamicut was re-designed by Ross in 1923.  Misquamicut has a significant architectural pedigree.  Golden Age architects Willie Park Jr, Tom Bendelow, and Seth Raynor all worked on the course before Ross completed his re-design.  Misquamicut is a course I have been trying to play for 15 years.  The season at Misquamicut is very short and I have been in the area a couple times too early (late April) or too late (October) in the season to have the opportunity to play it.  The course was well worth the wait.  Misquamicut is one of the most fun golf courses I have ever played!
3rd & 4th Holes

8th Hole

10th Hole

11th Hole

Garage & Driveway you drive through
Day three began at Agawam Hunt Club in Rumford, Rhode Island.  Agawam is a 1911 Ross re-design and is a hodgepodge of different architects and features one of the most unique routings I have ever seen.  You literally drive through a garage, down a driveway and across a busy street to get to and from holes 8 through 14.

3rd Hole

7th Hole

16th Hole
The second course I played on day three was Sakonnet Golf Club in Little Compton, Rhode Island.  Ross designed Sakonnet in 1922 and spent many summers just down the road, and like Pinehurst #2, he constantly tinkered with his design.
2nd Hole

4th Hole

8th Hole
18th Hole

The last course I played on day three was Point Judith Country Club in Narragansett, Rhode Island.  Donald Ross re-designed nine holes at Point Judith in 1927.  The front nine is very much a links course while most of the back nine is in the trees.
7th Hole

15th Hole

18th Hole
The final course I played on the trip was Knickerbocker Country Club in Tenafly, New Jersey.  Knickerbocker is a 1914 Donald Ross design with significant alterations by Geoffrey Cornish in the 1970's.  I will admit that of the courses I played on this trip, I knew the least about Knickerbocker.  I have played many courses in New Jersey but not in the very northern part where Knickerbocker is located.
5th Hole

11th Hole

16th Hole
My final thought on this trip is that I continue to be amazed at how good Ross was at routing a golf course.  I saw a wide variety of property on the trip and every single time Ross was able to route a course that maximized the land.   During the trip a friend called me and we were having a conversation about the modern minimalist architects and how even though their courses are great you eventually start to see a lot of sameness in their designs.  That is not the case with Donald Ross.  I played nine courses he designed or re-designed and I never saw the same thing.  He is truly the greatest.

Tuesday, May 8, 2018

Iowa Trip Review

Every year I try to take a trip to someplace I've never been and immerse myself in the golf courses of that area.  In 2017 that trip was to Iowa, state #46 in my quest to play golf in all 50 states.  I used my time well on this trip, playing 11 courses in five days.  While I did manage to hit most of the high points in Iowa, I wouldn't mind returning in the future.  The golf is very good.

My trip began at a course ranked in all of the various Top 100 Public courses list, The Harvester Golf Club in Rhodes, Iowa.  The Harvester was a great place to start my trip and I was very impressed by the course.  Keith Foster does great work renovating other people's courses, but this original design may be his best.  The property features great topography with elevation changes that do not feel as dramatic as you think they should be.  If you put The Harvester in California or Florida it would easily be ranked in the top 25 public courses in the country every year, but because it is located 30 minutes Northeast of Des Moines it will never get the attention it deserves.
2nd Hole.  I know it's not a great photo, but I holed out for Eagle on this hole, 120 yard wedge, didn't see it go in.

5th & 9th Holes

The OB is pretty severe on the 11th Hole. The goats on the other side of the fence were very friendly.  Golfers must feed them quite a bit because they ran over to me as soon as I got near the fence.


16th & 17th Holes
Day two of the trip began at Spirit Hollow Golf Course in Burlington, Iowa.  Spirit Hollow was designed by Rick Jacobson. I have played several Jacobson designs in the Middle Atlantic and this is by far his best course.  Jacobson has continued to tweak the course over the years, constantly trying to improve it.  I saw new tee boxes, adjusted fairway lines, and new bunkers while I was playing.  It's refreshing to see an ownership that is always striving to improve their course.
11th Hole

15th Hole

18th Hole
The second course on day two was Blue Top Ridge at Riverside Casino in Riverside, Iowa.  Blue Top Ridge was designed by Rees Jones and as always, he did a very good job of using the topography to give you a pleasant course that gives amble room off the tee.  I was particularly impressed by the long par 4's.

7th Hole
12th Hole

14th Hole
The third course on day two was Finkbine Golf Course in Iowa City.  Finkbine is the golf course for The University of Iowa and was designed by Robert Harris in the 50's.  Finkbine was a decent course with some good holes.  The thing I remember most was the unique double island green par 3 on the back nine.
6th Hole

Double Island Green 13th Hole
Day three of the trip began with a very pleasant surprise, Amana Colonies Golf Club in Amana, Iowa.  Amana was designed by William Spear in the late 80's.  I was shocked by the elevation changes.  I didn't realize it was possible to have a mountain course in Iowa, but that is exactly what this is.  It suffers from the same problems all mountain courses do; very tight in places, tough to hold fairways on severe elevations changes, but it is also very well designed.  The architect understood that players would be hitting from lots of uneven lies and gave you plenty of room around the greens.
3rd Hole

5th Hole

6th Hole
Cedar Rapids Country Club, designed by Donald Ross was next up on day three.  Cedar Rapids was restored by Ron Prichard, a Donald Ross restoration expert.  Ron did a great job at bringing back the strategic bunkering and undulating greens that we love in our Ross courses.  Similar to the next course I played on this day, Davenport Country Club, Cedar Rapids solidly belongs in the top 100 rankings.  Unfortunately, it's location means that it will likely never get enough raters to be considered.
1st Hole

6th Hole

18th Hole
The third course on day three was Davenport Country Club in Davenport, Iowa.  I have already written a blog post about Davenport, link is below.  I will emphasize that Davenport is one of the best courses in the mid-west and belongs in the Top 50 golf courses in the country.
Davenport Blog Post

Day four of the trip began with a sizable detour to the Chicago area to play Old Elm Club in Highland Park, Illinois.  Old Elm was designed by Harry Colt and built by Donald Ross.  Drew Rogers recently did an excellent renovation that recaptured the Colt feel.  The routing of the course hasn't changed one bit since it was built.  Old Elm is a Men's club and I know people are divided about the issue.  I will say that the vibe at Old Elm is one of the coolest I have ever seen.  They have a ping pong table in the golf shop.  Why?  Because they can.  The locker room is old fashioned and sensible and every single person you run into is laid back and friendly.
4th Hole

6th Hole
15th Hole
After a wonderful morning round at Old Elm, I made the five-hour drive back to Des Moines for a round on the North course at Des Moines Golf & Country Club.  Both courses at Des Moines are Pete Dye designs and Pete has been back recently to update the courses.  The Solheim Cup was played at Des Moines in the fall using the back nine of the North course and the front nine of the South Course.  I thought that was an interesting choice starting with the driveable 10th hole on the North course.  Interesting way of forcing you to think strategy right off the bat in a team competition.
8th Hole

11th Hole

15th Hole
The last day of the trip began with the only Tom Fazio course in the state of Iowa, Glen Oaks Country Club in West Des Moines.  Glen Oaks is in the middle of making improvements to the course but even with a few temporary holes, it was still a very enjoyable course.
4th and 5th Holes

9th Hole

11th Hole
The last round on the trip was the Langford & Moreau designed Wakonda Club.  Wakonda is a classic course that is fun to play and could really benefit from a proper restoration.  Tree removal, bunker restoration and green expansion could make this course one of the best.  The course hosts the Senior Tour in May which is why you will see bleachers in some of the photos.
2nd Hole

5th Hole

17th Hole



Florida Trip 2024

Depending on how you feel about my annual Florida trip profiles, you may or may not be happy to learn that this will likely be my last Flori...